In our earlier article, we’ve explained various factors to consider when changing a theme of your WordPress site. However, the difficult question comes before that step: how do you know when you should change your theme? If you’re wondering whether it’s the right time to change your WordPress theme, read on.
Changing a WordPress Theme
In general, you can go to “Appearance > Themes” in your admin panel and switch themes in a few clicks. In reality, however, it isn’t as easy as it sounds. You have to carefully choose a new theme that supports all the functions of your existing theme. On other hand, many site owners playing around changing the themes instead of focusing on creating content. This is one of the reasons, website builders like Wix and Squarespace don’t offer such a feature. This means, you can’t change the theme once the site is created (although you can customize). For a WordPress.org site, check the following factors to determine whether your site really needs a theme change.
1. It Isn’t Updated Regularly
WordPress receives frequent updates, and you need a quality theme that supports the latest version. PHP version and plugins are also updated to use the latest coding technology. Your theme should support and work seamlessly with the latest PHP version and other popular plugins. Unfortunately, many theme developers do not update their themes proactively. This can break your site when you use auto-update or update manually without proper testing.

If you’re considering a free theme from the WordPress.org theme repository, make sure it has been tested with the latest WordPress version. You’ll see a warning message if the developer has not declared compatibility with the latest WordPress updates. Since outdated themes can create security issues, you should immediately stop using themes that haven’t been tested for years.
Besides free themes, many outdated commercial themes are sold in marketplaces and on third-party websites. In many cases, you only discover problems after updating and then have to report them to the developer for bug fixes. That’s a poor way to maintain a commercial theme, and you should start looking for a replacement immediately.
2. Your Website is Slow
With page experience and Core Web Vitals, speed is one of the most important factors in improving your search engine rankings. If your theme is bloated and hurting your site speed, it’s high time to consider replacing it. Test your site with Google PageSpeed Insights, GTmetrix, or Pingdom to get a speed score. Then switch to a default theme or a simple theme like GeneratePress or Astra and test again. If the score increases dramatically (for example, from 50 to 90), your theme likely has problems affecting speed.

Although you can use caching plugins like WP Rocket, it doesn’t make sense to load 100 KB of unused CSS or JS on every page load because of your theme.
3. The Design Feels Boring
A high page speed score doesn’t automatically mean your theme is good. Many old websites score 100 out of 100 in Google PageSpeed Insights. However, visitors may still find the layout boring and leave quickly. Look for a theme that looks appealing, offers a positive user experience, and fits your needs.
4. It Has Too Many Features
A few years ago, it was trendy to offer hundreds of features in a single theme. Even today, you can find many themes on ThemeForest that offer too many features. For example, many popular commercial themes advertise things like:
- 100+ demos and optimization for WooCommerce.
- A custom page builder or header and footer builder..
- Social media integration.
- A custom theme panel with thousands of options (instead of using the default WordPress customizer).

If you’re currently using such a theme, we strongly recommend replacing it immediately before it’s too late. You may be happy now, but problems will arise when you want to change the theme after a few years. You may want to switch because of pricing, dissatisfaction with the developer’s support, or another reason. Removing all the theme’s features and moving to a new theme can become an impossible task. It’s always better to use a minimalist theme and add features with plugins instead of relying on a theme with too many built-in features.
On the other hand, as an individual website owner, you’ll never have time to use all the features available in such complex themes. For example, buying a WooCommerce optimized theme makes no sense if you don’t use WooCommerce at all or use Easy Digital Download.
5. You Spend Too Much Time on Optimization
Are you spending considerable time on page speed optimization? If so, remember one fact: page speed calculation methods are constantly evolving. Core Web Vitals didn’t exist a few years ago, and something new will certainly appear in the future. Big companies, agencies, and well-funded websites can invest heavily to adapt to these changes quickly. However, you may not be able to maintain your website if you start spending too much time on optimization.
The best solution is to use a simple, optimized WordPress theme. A simple theme like GeneratePress or Astra can help you achieve a 100/100 speed score even if you use a bunch of plugins installed for other purposes. You can make a one-time effort to replace your current theme and move to a simple theme that is already optimized for page speed.
6. It’s a Heavy JavaScript-Based Theme
Many WordPress themes use jQuery and heavy JavaScript for functionality. For example, you may be using a theme with a slideshow that requires JavaScript to load in the header. This creates render-blocking resources and reduces page speed considerably. It’s time to consider switching to a lightweight theme, and you can use plugins for a slideshow, gallery, and other features if needed.
7. It Comes Bundled with a Page Builder and Other Plugins
Did you purchase your current theme with bundled plugins? Consider the popular Newspaper theme offered on the ThemeForest marketplace. It offers a custom page builder called tagDiv Composer and nine other premium plugins. Similarly, there is also a Pixwell magazine style theme that comes with a custom page builder. When these plugins are tightly integrated, switching themes can break your layouts and require replacing each bundled tool. That’s another sign it may be time to move to a cleaner, more flexible setup.

8. It Relies on Shortcodes
Shortcodes are completely outdated with the introduction of the block-based Gutenberg editor. If you’re primarily relying on copying and pasting shortcodes throughout your site’s pages, rethink what you’re doing. At some point, there will be no easy way to clean up those shortcodes inserted into your post content. These shortcodes will look ugly on the front end when you switch to another theme, and your only option may be to manually clean up each post.

9. It Uses Custom Fonts
It’s time to consider an alternative, if your theme uses multiple fonts for elements like navigation, body, title, etc. Gone are the days when you loved hosting your own fonts. Later, the trend moved to Google Fonts, and now it is moving toward system font stacks. If your current theme uses custom or Google Fonts, consider moving to a theme that uses system fonts.
10. It Isn’t Optimized for Gutenberg Block Support
Gutenberg is a core WordPress feature and has already changed many old parts of the admin panel. For example, WordPress version 5.8 introduced the block-based widget editor, removing the years-old widget area screen. Check whether your theme fully supports Gutenberg blocks and widgets, including full-width and wide-width elements. In addition, get rid of themes that use custom post types requiring the Classic Editor.

Final Words
If you’re unsure whether to change your current WordPress theme, consider these three factors: speed, design, and usability. In fact, all the above explained points can be categorized under one of these three factors. For example, your current theme may have high speed and a good-looking design. However, it may lag in usability because it relies on custom a page builder plugin, uses shortcodes, and doesn’t support Gutenberg blocks. In that case, stop using such a theme and look for one that won’t cause problems when you switch again.





